Wiliams Divorce & Family Law Logo

NOT SURE IF WE CAN HELP?Request your free 30 minute consultOR CALL US AT 651-332-7650

  • Home
  • Our Staff
    • Attorney Gerald O. Williams
    • Paralegal Jocelyn Daul
  • Practice Areas
    • Alimony
    • Child Custody
    • Child Support
    • Collaborative Divorce
    • Divorce
    • International Custody
    • Interstate Custody
    • LGBTQIA+ Divorce & Custody
    • Mediation
  • Billing
    • Billing FAQ
    • Flat Fee Divorce
    • Flat Fee Mediation
  • Blog
  • Courts
    • Dakota County Family Courts
    • Hennepin County Family Court
    • Ramsey County Family Courts
    • Washington County Family Court
  • Clients
    • Make Payment
    • Secure File Upload
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Directions to Williams Divorce and Family Law
    • Privacy Policy

Neutral Vocational Evaluations

Posted by Gerald Williams 
· March 6, 2020 
· No Comments

When a couple is divorcing, issues may arise regarding the present earnings, past earnings, future earnings or potential earnings of one or both spouses. This happens most commonly when one party is seeking spousal maintenance (a/k/a alimony), and the other party believes the requesting party is under-employed. That term (under-employed) refers to (a) working less than full-time and/or (b) foregoing the opportunity for higher level earnings. In most cases, the dispute can be resolved by negotiating the issue in conjunction with other financial issues, such as retirement assets or house equity – oftentimes with a mediator.

But if the parties need a vocational expert to weigh in on the issue, most commonly it is because the spouse who would pay spousal maintenance would like to show how much higher the requesting spouse’s income could be. This spouse might be tempted to hire an expert to focus on the potential income and estimate as high as possible. That would require the requesting spouse to hire a competing expert to focus on the realities of the job market and the obstacles and limitations that stand in the way of maximum earnings. If the parties litigate the issue in family court, then the judge is presented with two extremes, neither of which is likely the fair answer to the question. Nor is it likely to be a fair result for the court to simply average the opinions of the two experts. Nor is the court in the best-informed position hearing from experts advocating for one “side” of the legal dispute.

If the parties agree to enlist a neutral vocational expert, they will likely share the cost of the expert’s work (which saves each party half of what they would likely spend on their own experts), and the work product will be a better way to provide the court with an informed record on which to make a decision. Moreover, the parties may avoid the need to let the court decide the issue altogether, if the parties are able to agree that the neutral expert’s opinion is a satisfactory middle ground.

No Comments
Categories : Financial Issues
Previous Post →
← Next Post

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts

  • Summary Real Estate Disposition Judgment
  • Custody Evaluations
  • In Camera Interviews of Children
  • Guardians Ad Litem
  • Certificate of Dissolution

Categories

  • Alimony / Spousal Maintenance (8)
  • Child Custody (42)
  • Child Support (21)
  • Co-parenting (1)
  • Court of Appeals (2)
  • Divorce (45)
  • Financial Issues (2)
  • General Family Law (53)
  • Guardian ad litem (6)
  • Interstate issues (2)
  • Mediation (5)
  • Mental Health (3)
  • Parenting Plans (1)
  • Parenting Time (17)
  • Parenting time expeditor (3)
  • Same Sex Divorce (5)
  • Uncategorized (28)
  • Uncontested Divorce (6)
Copyright © 2023 Williams Divorce & Family Law All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy

The content of this website is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or an attorney-client relationship. To establish an attorney-client relationship with Williams Divorce & Family Law requires a retainer agreement signed by you and attorney Gerald O. Williams. Woodbury/St. Paul, Minnesota, attorney, Gerald O. Williams, represents clients in divorce and family law matters throughout the seven county metro area, including the communities of St. Paul, Minneapolis, Eagan, Inver Grove Heights, Cottage Grove, Maplewood, Oakdale, Lake Elmo, and Stillwater. The seven county metro area includes Washington, Ramsey, Hennepin, Dakota, Anoka, Scott, and Carver.

Is court in person? Court Covid Update